2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey (Large Libraries) Update

2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey: Larger Libraries (Over $5 million operating budget)

Library Survey Roster: Akron, Cleveland, Columbus, Cuyahoga Count, Dayton, Delaware County, Geauga County, Greene County, Lane, Medina County, Middletown, Stark County, Worthington, Youngstown

 

   Circulation (in millions) 

25th    50th    Avg.      75th

        Operating Budget                 (in millions)   

25th    50th  Avg 75th         

           F.T.E. 

25th      50th  Avg. 75th

Larger Libraries(Operating budget over  $5 mil.) 2.60     3.40    6.34    7.30 8.5    12.9  23.3 44.0 113.4 229.0 283.1 407.5

 

Title # Libraries # of F.T.E. 25th % 50th % Average Rate 75th %
Director 14 14 $48.11 $56.31 $58.76 $67.75
Fiscal Officer 14 14 $30.86 $35.00 $41.85 $49.89
HR Manager 12 14 $27.98 $34.08 $34.83 $40.77
Head, Tech. Services 14 14 $27.45 $30.62 $38.67 $42.12
Head, Children’s 12 18 $23.41 $29.42 $30.34 $36.54
Head Circulation 13 44 $20.14 $24.98 $24.68 $29.72
PR/Marketing Specialist 13 13.8 $22.95 $26.82 $29.16 $36.07
MLS Librarian 13 282.5 $19.67 $22.67 $22.59 $24.83
Children’s Librarian 12 211.7 $17.79 $20.96 $20.51 $24.33
Cataloger 14 25.8 $17.87 $21.15 $21.15 $24.60
Librarian (no MLS) 7 133.4 $14.49 $15.73 $18.97 $22.01
Circulation Clerk 13 485.3 $10.80 $12.41 $13.23 $15.56

Survey Tips

Tips on How to Use the 2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey

  1. Choose your competitive set. There are three (3) primary tables: Smaller libraries, Larger libraries and All libraries. All libraries can be used as a proxy for “in-between” small and large. Consult budget, circulation and FTE parameters in the Characteristics table as a guide.
  2.  Select your targets and strategy. Examples:
  • If your library is meaningfully larger or smaller than the relevant competitive set you may want to use the 75th or 25th percentile rates, respectively, as your target rates.
  • If you want to use the measure of central tendency, the median (i.e., 50th percentile) is usually the more representative number. The differences in the average and median rates, if they are significant, are an indication of skewing caused by very low or very high rates in the data set.
  • You may want to consider differential targets based on recruiting difficulties or strategic objectives. Examples might include using 50th percentile targets for all jobs except Head of Technical Services and Circulation Clerk because you have had extreme difficulty recruiting and retaining T.S. department heads and you want to be best in class in customer service. A 75th percentile target would differentially focus on the two jobs of concern.

2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey

Akron Public LibraryBrown County Public Library

Cleveland Public Library

Cuyahoga County Public Library

Dayton Metro Library

Delaware County District Library

Fairfield County District Library

Geauga County District Library

Greene County Public Library

Huron County Library District

Lane Public Library

Licking County Library

Medina County District LibraryMentor Public Library

Middletown Public Library

Muskingum County Library System

Rocky River Public Library

Sandusky Library

Shaker Heights Public Library

Stark County District Library

Tuscarawas County Public Library

Worthington Libraries

Public Library of Youngstown & Mahoning County

 

2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey                               All Libraries

Title # Libraries # of F.T.E. 25th % 50th % Average Rate 75th %
Director 23 22.9 $41.34 $48.11 $47.92 $55.87
Fiscal Officer 23 22.9 $28.43 $32.11 $33.44 $41.45
HR Manager 14 14 $26.06 $31.79 $30.64 $37.73
Head, Tech. Services 22 22 $20.83 $27.12 $29.54 $34.32
Head, Children’s 20 25.9 $20.91 $24.33 $27.31 $34.74
Head Circulation 20 50.9 $19.27 $22.04 $24.36 $27.89
PR/Marketing Specialist 16 16.8 $20.11 $25.81 $27.98 $35.71
MLS Librarian 21 310.5 $19.25 $21.68 $21.52 $23.22
Children’s Librarian 16 210.5 $16.72 $20.33 $19.35 $22.10
Cataloger 16 29.6 $17.12 $20.18 $20.17 $22.36
Librarian (no MLS) 13 155.8 $14.24 $16.49 $17.49 $19.78
Circulation Clerk 21 138.9 $10.57 $11.21 $12.00 $12.64

 

 

2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey: Larger Libraries (Over $5 million operating budget)

Title # Libraries # of F.T.E. 25th % 50th % Average Rate 75th %
Director 13 13 $45.66 $53.67 $56.16 $65.28
Fiscal Officer 13 13 $30.55 $33.89 $38.52 $47.04
HR Manager 11 11 $27.24 $32.84 $34.70 $40.77
Head, Tech. Services 13 13 $26.73 $30.56 $35.47 $46.14
Head, Children’s 11 17 $22.77 $27.13 $29.32 $30.52
Head Circulation 12 43 $20.14 $24.73 $24.47 $34.05
PR/Marketing Specialist 12 12.8 $20.84 $25.03 $29.21 $36.07
MLS Librarian 12 259.5 $19.58 $22.67 $22.32 $24.33
Children’s Librarian 11 197.7 $17.79 $20.66 $20.03 $23.45
Cataloger 13 23.8 $18.61 $20.58 $20.61 $24.60
Librarian (no MLS) 7 133.4 $14.49 $15.73 $18.97 $22.01
Circulation Clerk 12 23.8 $10.76 $12.17 $13.10 $16.52

2012 Ohio Public Library Compensation Survey:  Smaller Libraries (Under $5 million operating budget)

Title # Libraries # of F.T.E. 25th % 50th % Average Rate 75th %
Director 10 9.9 $28.48 $38.71 $39.76 $52.89
Fiscal Officer 10 9.9 $20.35 $29.93 $27.85 $32.76
HR Manager 3 3 InsufficientSample InsufficientSample InsufficientSample InsufficientSample
Head, Tech. Services 9 9 $17.35 $20.83 $21.81 $25.94
Head, Children’s 9 8.9 $20.81 $23.82 $22.91 $26.14
Head Circulation 8 7.9 $16.15 $22.04 $21.12 $24.69
PR/Marketing Specialist 4 4 InsufficientSample InsufficientSample Insufficient Sample InsufficientSample
MLS Librarian 9 51 $19.09 $21.64 $20.54 $22.15
Children’s Librarian 5 12.8 InsufficientSample $20.30 $17.90 InsufficientSample
Cataloger 4 5.8 InsufficientSample InsufficientSample InsufficientSample InsufficientSample
Librarian (no MLS) 6 22.4 InsufficientSample $17.31 $16.35 Insufficient Sample
Circulation Clerk 9 115.1 $9.07 $10.88 $10.79 $12.39

 

 

Testimonials

The Middletown Public Library has worked with Jerry Stepp some twenty years.  He has been our prime consultant in all areas of human resources: job descriptions, performance appraisals, compensation, and teambuilding.  The list goes on.  Jerry has done the heavy lifting on recruitment and hiring for top positions including recruiting my successor.  He finds a way to make a hard job enjoyable.  Somewhere along the line you’ll laugh.  Perhaps it’s because he has an exceptional grasp of human nature.  He really knows people.

The unique thing about Jerry is that he has the trust of front-line staff, management, and trustees.  That’s invaluable. Jerry is a member of the team and is well known and respected throughout the organization.

Jerry is prompt, efficient, and readily available.  When I’ve needed him, I’ve picked up the phone and dialed him.  He answers. 

Jerry is a reader and a strong advocate for public libraries. 

Doug Bean, former Director of The Middletown Public Libraries

The Middletown Public Library System retained Stepp Associates to conduct a search to replace our Director who retired after 36 years. Jerry did a great job for us! We are very pleased with our new Director. Jerry handled all aspects of our successful search. He recruited, screened, and vetted the candidates,and presented our board with four very good choices to interview. He is very professional, flexible, knowlegeable, and great to work with!!

Jim Vonderhaar, President of the Middletown Library Board of Trustees

 

Endorsement: Jerry Stepp, Stepp Associates

The Lane Public Library Board of Trustees contracted with Jerry Stepp, Stepp Associates, in our search for a director for the library system after the retirement of our director, who had served for 27 years. In my capacity of President of the Board, and member of the Director Search Committee, I had the opportunity to work with Mr. Stepp over a period of about four months.

In preparing the Board and Search Committee for the critical pursuit of a director who would successfully fill a position held by the long-term director Mr. Stepp’s knowledge of recent library director searches in the area was invaluable. He was able to quickly and actively recruit viable candidates for the position. During the search process, Mr. Stepp diligently moved the process forward and proactively brought the group to a well-reasoned consensus. The committee worked conscientiously and attentively toward our goal, with Mr. Stepp always attentive to the committee’s need for essential details and qualifications.

Mr. Stepp’s efficient process and effective facilitation eased the decision process. Negotiation with the chosen candidate was similarly competent. In the follow-up period, with the new director in place, Mr. Stepp has followed through to act as a coach, for the administrator as well as the Board.

In the preparation period, the search process, and in the post-search period Mr. Stepp has proven to be extremely knowledgeable in many critical areas – library administrative needs and qualifications, search strategy, evaluation of candidates, facilitation of a team, and administrative guidance. The Board of Trustees is pleased by the excellent guidance and consultation provided by Jerry Stepp in the search for our director position.

Cheryl D. Young

President, Lane Public Library Board of Trustees

29 July 2011

 

Purposeful Performance

Work is purposeful activity. which means that all work is activity but not all activity is work. How can you make sure that your organization is working and not merely busy? One way is to create focus and alignment of purpose. Everyone in the organization, from C.E.O. to File Clerk, needs to be focused on the core purpose(s) and their actions aligned to that purpose(s). I’m going to walk you through several management practices, which if viewed and executed through this prism will make you a more purposeful and productive enterprise.

Strategy

Maybe you have a fat binder gathering dust on a bookshelf that speaks to the strategic plan. If you do, try to distil it down to one page. Or maybe it would be easier to start from scratch. In any event, what you want is a list of up to 5 things that speak to why your organization exists and how it may prosper in the future. The following is a somewhat dated example of the raison d’etre for the Athens County Public Library in Ohio.

  •        Provides customer service that is timely, thorough, friendly and helpful.
  •        Educates and entertains customers through programming for children, families and other specialized audiences.
  •        Promotes and provides access to services, collections and information.
  •        Provides safe, inviting and functional facilities and equipment.

Jobs

Jobs are bundles of work. I say work instead of tasks because each task needs to connote work instead of merely activity. The following excerpt from an Athens County Public Library job description organizes the work of a position according to the purpose being fulfilled. Writing job descriptions in this way helps you to identify non-value added activity. If employees are engaged in activity that does not fulfill a purpose eliminate the activity.

       Promotes and provides access to services, collections and information:

  1. Promotes the library in the community at every opportunity.
  2. Posts signs and places advertisements to advertise library events.
  3. Visits schools to inform them of services and to encourage visits.
  4. Represents the library at meetings, conferences, presentations and workshops.
  5. Develops comunity partnerships for the purpose of enhancing library services.

Competencies

You need a purpose(s). You need work that fulfills a purpose(s). Therefore you need competencies that allow you to perform the work. 

The base of the Competency model is Innate Capacity. We are not all created equally. We have varying capacities to learn. There is nothing you can do about Innate Capacity. The lesson is to learn how to make smart hires. A smart hire is about capacity rather than credentials although the two need not be mutually exclusive.

Readiness is about education and acculturation. It’s the refinement and development of Innate Capacity. Formal education forms the baseline for skills development and the quality of our upbringing forms our disposition toward the world. Knowledge and Attitude are, to a degree, malleable qualities but by the time one is of employment age the foundation should already be laid.

Performance involves the application of skills and behaviors that are developed on the job. Any organization that takes competencies seriously also takes training and coaching seriously. Your job is to build performance competencies, measure the application of those competencies and continually shore up deficiencies.

Outcomes refer to aggregate performance, the realization of purposeful goals and strategies that demonstrate a competent, high-performance organization.

The Customer Focus array below is a simplified example of a measurement tool that describes Ineffective, Effective and Exemplary performance.

Customer Focus

 1                                                                2                             3                                 4                                                                5

            Ineffective               Effective                 Exemplary
Allows clerical or “off desk” duties to interfere with customer service. Sees to customer demands at one’s own convenience. Views customer service as a burden. Behavior reflects the belief that the customer is always to library’s top priority. Treats all customers fairly without playing favorites or holding grudges. Empathizes with the customer. Looks at every transaction as an opportunity to serve.
Performs customer service begrudgingly – as a mindless routine rather than a series of interpersonal transactions. Carries on personal conversations in front of customers In every situation, listens to the customer’s needs and responds accordingly. Avoids passing the buck. Anticipates needs. Offers assistance before being asked. Exceeds expectations. Follows up to insure satisfaction.
Favors an adversarial relationship with customers. May be too rigid in enforcement of policies and rules. Corrects or chastises customers. Works within established guidelines to allow every customer to have a positive experience at the library. Gives customers the benefit of the doubt. Suggests and promotes policies and procedures that ae as customer friendly as possible. Feels empowered to suggest solutions when extenuating circumstances arise.

Compensation

If performance is variable then so should compensation. The compensation band below is an example of a market-based range for a job(s) at varying degrees of competency and performance.

Min.   1st Quartile                          2nd Quartile            Mid       3rd Quartile                       4th Quartile        Max

$12.00 $14.00 $16.00 $18.00                  $20.00
           Novice      Practitioner        Master           Mentor

The band is segmented into 4 quartiles labeled Novice, Practitioner, Master and Mentor.

Novice: The minimum rate is the market rate below which you would find no acceptable candidate for the job. The Novice segment of the range is appropriate for newer employers who are acquiring baseline competencies and are performing at acceptable standards.

Practitioner: The Practitioner segment (2nd quartile) is the range of pay appropriate for a fully trained, fully competent employee. The midpoint rate approximates the median market rate for the job.

Master: The Master segment (3rd quartile) is reserved for advanced competencies and high performance.

Mentor: The Mentor segment (4th quartile) represents pay appropriate for maximally competent, high performers who also have the ability to transfer skills to others (trainer and coach) and lead (Supervisor).

Integrating compensation and competencies systems requires mapping specific competencies and performance expectations to the various segments of the pay band.

What I have described is an organization where purposeful strategies are realized through value-adding work and supported by and motivated by competencies and compensation. What I have described is nothing short of the purposefully performing organization.

Library Leaders Must Chart the Course to Tomorrow – Today

Libraries are changing whether you like it or not. The old warehousing and distribution model is giving way to something new. Similarly, library leaders are becoming more transformational than operational. This doesn’t mean that Library Directors will no longer have to worry about budgets and management issues. It just means that a new set of competencies and priorities will move to the forefront.  Here are a few of them: 

  •        New Media: Television didn’t make radio disappear and I don’t think the book is an obsolete relic. It just has a new digital partner. What e-books excel at are accessibility and portability. I once traveled with, pound for pound, more books than clothes but those days are over. E-books have the added advantage of being accessible as a remote download . E-books give Libraries access to new markets both geographically and technologically. Library leaders must embrace digital media instead of defending the book. The book doesn’t need your help. The book will take care of itself.
  •       Social Media: It matters not at all whether the Library Director has a Facebook page or Linked-In account or whether he or she tweets (although I think it’s a pretty good idea). What matters is that the Director understands the power and reach of social media and uses it to full advantage. Social media, like e-books, stretch boundaries and delivers information and services to those who can’t or won’t visit a brick and mortar library.
  •       Collaboration: It’s time to tear down the walls. Shared catalogs. Joint marketing. Libraries can leverage their respective strengths and coordinate resources and services with other libraries to provide customers with more for less. And they should. There are also opportunities to partner with the private sector on training and job search/placement services that won’t compromise the library’s central mission.
  •      Community Centers: Public space has been eroding in America for decades. The current push for privatization of anything and everything threatens to accelerate the trend. A functioning democracy needs places where citizens can freely and peacefully assemble outside of corporate control. As the library becomes less of a warehouse it should become more of a community center.
  •        Community Relation (i.e., “gasp” politics): I believe a library leader should spend at least as much time outside the library as inside. The Director should join civic and business organizations, solicit and accept speaking engagements, write articles and do everything else they can do to advocate and lobby for the library. Make sure your community understands your essential role in educating, informing and protecting America’s freedom. This requires that you have a strong team in place to handle operational issues when you are away. Get out and get it done!
  •       Entertainment: Yes, you read that right. Customers think of readings by authors, lectures, art exhibits and performances by string quartets as entertainment. They think programming is something that computer geeks do. Make your library a destination for fun, learning and, yes, entertainment. Thin culture and entertainment and do a lot more of it.

 Public libraries will have a future so long as library leaders have a vision and possess the competencies to realize the vision. Change is in the air. Embrace it.

The public library is dead. Long live the public library!

The Search: Part 1

The Search Committee:

I like to work with a Search Committee of 5 to 7 members. A Committee of fewer than 5 members is unlikely to have the diversity of perspective required for balanced decision-making. A Committee of more than 7 is unwieldy, difficult to schedule for meetings and slow.

While the most important criteria for Committee membership are intelligence, open mindedness and having the interests of the library at heart, a typical membership roster for a library looks like the following:

  •       The Search Professional (i.e., me)
  •       3 Current Board Members including the President
  •       1 or 2 prominent community members. Individuals who have served as Board members in the past or prospective future Board members are ideal. In any event, they should be active and respected in the community and have some knowledge of the library. At the very least they should be library cardholders.
  •       In the case of a Search for a successor to a retiring Director, I like to have the exiting Director on the Committee.
  •       The Human Resources Manager should either be a voting member of the Committee or an advisor. He/she has valuable information about benefits, perquisites and the hiring/on-boarding process.

 The Committee would meet to kick-off the Search by:

  •        Reviewing the Search Agreement
  •        Reviewing the Strategic Plan and Mission
  •        Establishing candidate requirements
  •        Determining geographic search parameters, compensation parameters and to review hiring and interviewing legalities.

After the initial meeting the Search Professional begins to source candidates through job postings, networking and evaluating degree of fit of available talent from previous Searches.This process typically takes 4 to 6 weeks during which the Search Professional keeps the Committee updated via periodic emails. The Search Professional will pre-qualify candidates through phone or in-person interviews.

Once 3 to 5 viable and attractive candidates have been identified the Search Committee will meet to plan the interviews. The Search Professional will facilitate brainstorming to draft a list of interview questions and will brief the Committee on each of the candidate’s qualifications and competencies. The interviews will be scheduled with as little elapsed time between interview sessions as possible. This makes comparisons between candidate styles and abilities fresh and easy. It’s the Search Professional’s role to keep the Committee focused on the agreed upon process, requirements and other salient issues.

The interview and evaluation process will yield a preferred candidate who will be vetted through reference and background checks and, sometimes, a behavioral assessment. The recommended candidate is presented to the full Board for approval. It is usually the Board that extends the formal offer of employment through the Search Professional. The Board will empower the Search Professional to negotiate a compensation package within not-to-exceed guidelines.

The Search Agreement may provide for a leadership transition plan, designed by the Search Professional, based on the new hire’s behavioral assessment profile.

 

 

Lane Director Search

 

Congratulations: Joe Greenward, New Director of Lane Libraries 

Library Director:  The Lane Libraries : Butler County (SW) Ohio

Lane Libraries seek a Library Director. We require a strategic and service-minded leader who understands library operations and has strong interpersonal, communications, people management and planning skills. The successful candidate understands the benefits of emerging technologies. The Library Director is expected to be involved in the community and be able to build consensus for action. Minimum qualifications include a Masters in Library Science and several years of relevant experience.

Lane Libraries serve western Butler County, Ohio, with an operating budget of $5.2 mil., 68 F.T.E. employees and a circulation of 2.2 mil.

Candidates should send a cover letter, resume, 3 references and salary expectations to:

Stepp Associates

312 Walnut St.

Suite 1600

Cincinnati, Ohio 45202

Or via email: steppassociates@cinoh.com

The application deadline is April 30, 2011.

Library Director: Middletown Public Library

 

Position Filled: Congratulations to Anita Carroll, the new Middletown Library Director

Library Director

Middletown Public Library System

The Middletown Libraries seek a Library Director. We require a strategic and service- minded leader who understands library operations and has interpersonal, financial, people management and planning skills. The Library Director is expected to be involved in the community and be able to build consensus for action. Minimum qualifications include a Masters in Library Science and several years of relevant experience.

The Middletown Libraries serve eastern Butler County, Ohio, with an operating budget of $5.2 mil., 70 F.T.E. employees and a circulation of 2.2 mil.

Candidates should send a cover letter, resume, 3 references and salary expectations to:

Stepp Associates

312 Walnut St.

Suite 1600

Cincinnati, Ohio 45202

Or via email: steppassociates@cinoh.com

The application deadline is December 1, 2010.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.